Best Plush Dog Toys For Various Levels of Play

By Coty Perry

Plush dog toys are meant to be cuddly, fun, and durable enough to withstand even the most aggressive chewers. They’re meant to be that way but that doesn’t mean they always are. 

In this guide, we’re covering some of the best plush dog toys that are not only fun for your pup but durable enough to hold up against some serious abuse. 

4 Best Plush Dog Toys: Our Favorites 

Here are our favorite picks for the best plush dog toys: 

Bonne et Filou Macaron Squeaky Toy

Best Overall 

4.6 out of 5 

  • Incredibly cute design
  • Super soft plush material
  • Each macaron comes with a built-in squeaker
  • Made using non-toxic and recycled materials 

These toys look more like delicious desserts than they do toys! These unique macaron dog toys are squeaky, cute, and incredibly fun, 

The pack comes with six macaron chew toys that are included inside of a dessert style box. Each comes with a squeaker and they come in three different colors. 

This fun and unique design is great for fetching, playing, or cuddling. The ultra soft material is gentle on your pups skin and the perfect choice for small or medium dogs that do not play too rough with their toys. 

Keep in mind that these are not the most durable dog toys on the market so if you have an aggressive chewer, you’ll want to stick around for our second choice. 

Outward Hound Invincible Snake

Best Plus Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers

4.3 out of 5 

  • Designed for ultimate durability
  • Double-layered fabric for chew resistance
  • Does not contain stuffing
  • Comes in three sizes

If you’ve got a dog that seems to tear apart basically any toy you give them, this is the toy you want to try out. Keep in mind that nothing is indestructible and some dogs will find their way no matter what. 

This snake toy uses a dura-tuff lining reinforced with two layers to help prevent your dog from chewing through it. The toy does not contain stuffing so they can’t rip it up and throw it everywhere. 

It comes in three sizes with a three-squeak, six-squeak, and 12-squeak option depending on the size of your dog. 

This toy is a lot bigger than you would think with the smallest three-squeak option extending for more than two-feet in length.  

Frisco Plush Squeaking Cow

Best Plush Toys for Puppies 

4.4 out of 5

  • Comes with a built-in squeaker and rope
  • Soft fabric makes it a great toy for cuddling too
  • Limited stuffing inside
  • Not for aggressive chewers 

Sometimes we’re looking for the best plush dog toys that can be a fun playtime toy while also serving as a stuffed animal for sleep and rest. This is a great option if that’s what you’re in search of. 

The Frisco brand is the Chewy brand of products and we’re big fans of their manufacturing and the quality of most of the things they put out. 

This toy comes with a built-in rope that allows your pup to get a little rough with the toy. The squeaker will also get them all excited and riled up each time they bite down on it. 

The Squeaking Cow has a soft fabric making it ideal for naptime and the minimal stuffing used makes it less of an issue if your dog does rip it open. 

KONG Wild Knots Bear Dog Toy

Best Large Plush Dog Toy with Squeakers 

4.2 out of 5

  • Minimal stuffing to reduce messes
  • Extra-large toy for big breeds
  • Various color options
  • Squeaks for exciting playtime  

This toy is soft and cuddly on the outside with a rope on the inside for playtime. If you’re looking for a soft companion for your large breed dog, this option from KONG could be the one. Watch them carry their new toy around and bring it everywhere they go from naptime to playtime. 

Keep in mind that no toy is indestructible and this one is not necessarily designed for rough play. If you notice that pieces are falling off and they’re starting to tear it apart, we recommend removing it. 

The toy contains minimal stuffing so if your pup does manage to break through, it’ll reduce the mess and decrease the chances of them ingesting too much of the stuffing. 

Choosing the Best Plush Dog Toy

How can you choose just one toy when there are so many options available? The answer is, you can’t. Get them all!

Okay, just kidding, but there’s some thought that should go into buying a plushie for your pup. 

If they’re a rough chewer for example, you’ll need to choose wisely otherwise the toy will be ripped to shreds before you even have a chance to break down the box. 

Here are some things to keep in mind when shopping around. 


The durability or lack thereof is going to be one of the most important factors in choosing the best plush dog toy. It’s important to understand that no toy is off limits when it comes to your dog so the chances of them destroying anything is there. 

That said, some dogs are more prone to anxiety when you leave which could cause them to become destructive. This could lead to them purposely destroying their toys. 

For some pups, it’s just natural. They play too rough with the toy and throw it all over the place. It’s fun for them and there isn’t necessarily anything you do about it. 

The smartest move in most cases would be to reserve plush dog toys for relaxation time. Try to teach your dog that they’ll only keep their plushie around when it’s time to lay down or go to sleep. Use the other rope or ball toys when it’s time to play rough. 

Type of Activity 

What types of features are you looking for in the dog toy? Do you want a rope toy, a fetch toy, or something completely different? Some dogs don’t like to fetch while others are uninterested in playing rough. 

It’s important to understand that a toy should appeal to your dog and not what you think they should like. 

Final Thoughts 

The best plush dog toy is soft, fun, and durable enough to last at least long enough for your pup to enjoy it. 

The Bonne et Filou Macaron Squeaky Toy is our favorite option because it’s adorable, fun, and unique. We’re sure your dog will absolutely love it and if they accidentally break one of the macarons, it’s okay because you have five more! 

If you need something seriously durable, the Outward Hound Invincible Snake is the only real option for soft plush toys. They have a number of options too if your dog doesn’t like the snake. 

Photo of author
Coty Perry
Coty is a self-proclaimed cat whisperer and animal lover. Growing up his mom ran a dog training business out of his childhood home so you can say it was complete chaos 24/7. Today, when he comes home after a long day of writing about animals, he’s greeted by his two loving cats Marley and Cozmo.